One classroom management strategy that has stood the test of time is the good old behavior chart. Behavior charts have long been controversial with people either praising them or criticizing them. Some argue they provide structure while others say they lead to negative behaviors and public shaming. Here weāll explore the history of student behavior charts in education, and examine the pros and cons. Then weāll address the question if they are truly beneficial for the students.
The History of Student Behavior Charts
Behavior charts have been used in classrooms for decades. In the 1920ās they were used to monitor attendance and punctuality, then according to the in the 1980s and 1990ās they shifted towards behavioral management and incorporated positive reinforcement. In the late 1990ās as many as 70% of elementary school teachers were using some behavior chart in the classroom, according to a study published in the .
Today, a survey by the (NCES) notes that 65% of elementary school teachers living in the U.S. reported using behavior charts or a similar system in their classrooms. 75% of these teachers found that they helped studentsā behavior. However, 55% expressed concern about how they affected their . Ultimately, the idea behind behavior charts was to find an immediate way for students to see that their actions had consequences and understand that they must be held accountable for their actions.
The Pros of Student Behavior Charts
Student behavior charts can be beneficial in the classroom. Here are a few of the advantages.
Clear Expectations
Behavior charts provide a clear framework for students to understand what is and is not expected of them and the consequences of their actions. When students know what is expected of them and they know that the rules are consistently enforced, they are more likely to follow them.
Immediate Feedback
Behavior charts give students immediate feedback about their behavior. For example, if a child is helping a classmate, they may be asked to move their sticker up the chart or if a child is interrupting in class, they may move a notch down. This feedback helps young students connect their actions with real-time consequences.
Positive Reinforcement
Some behavior charts for good behavior or helping others. Students can earn stickers or move up on a chart to earn positive reinforcement. This can help motivate students to strive for more positive behavior, resulting in a more positive classroom atmosphere.
The Cons of Student Behavior Charts
While behavior charts have advantages, they can also have disadvantages. Here are some of the notable drawbacks.
Damaging to Self-Esteem
One of the main criticisms of behavior charts is that they can be humiliating for children. When a childās negative behavior is showcased for all to see, it can damage a childās self-esteem. Publicly highlighting these mistakes may lead to embarrassment and undermine their confidence. This can create a harmful, negative cycle where the child continues the negative behavior because they feel they are not worthy.
Excessive Focus on Negative Behavior
Behavior charts that focus solely or too much on a studentās negative behavior can create a negative learning environment. For example, if a chart is used to punish an undesirable action, rather than encourage a positive one, then it may create a negative cycle which will foster a negative atmosphere.
Short-Term Fix
Behavior charts are a quick solution to managing behavior. While they may reward good behavior and penalize negative behavior, they donāt equip students with the skills they need to change that behavior. To truly change a studentās negative behavior, you must address the root cause in addition to using the chart. This will help students build the skills needed to manage their behavior.
Are Student Behavior Charts Beneficial?
This is a complex question that depends on the student’s needs and how the behavior chart is implemented in the classroom. For younger students, the immediate feedback that behavior charts give, as well as the structure they provide, can help guide their behavior and help them develop better self-regulation skills. However, the effectiveness of the chart depends on how it is implemented in the classroom.
On the other hand, some older students may not benefit from a behavior chart because they may require a more nuanced approach that needs to address an underlying behavior issue. Since behavior charts are useful for basic compliance, the chart may not lead to a genuine behavior change.
Overall, behavior charts can be useful tools for managing behavior, but to be effective, they must be tailored to each student’s individual needs and used alongside other strategies.
Tips for Maximizing Benefits and Minimizing Drawbacks
With behavior charts, itās essential to focus on a studentās positive behavior and achievements and celebrate their successes. Involve students in setting behavior goals and tracking their progress. Be sure to prevent public shaming by talking to students privately and using individual charts. Make your expectations clear so students will trust the system. Finally, be flexible and adapt the system as needed to ensure individual studentsā needs are being met.
Behavior charts can be a helpful tool in managing your classroom, but their success ultimately depends on how you use them. Tailoring them to meet the needs of students and using them in combination with other strategies can be an effective approach. By focusing on positive behaviors, keeping them private to avoid public shaming, and being clear and consistent with your expectations, you can create a positive, supportive classroom environment.
Are you interested in pursuing your education graduate degree? Check out our to advance your career today!Ā
